which is a better bike

[jc]

the Haro V3, or the Gaint Yukon?
thanks.

[JIMMYC]

Try this web site.
www.mtbr.com

[ted]

Between the two, the Giant has a few parts that are a step above the Haro. It's only a handful of parts, but it makes a $30 difference. If you think you can tell the difference, then you need to come do my job.
Yes, yes, yes, the Giant has disc brakes, but a good set of V-brakes is way better than any entry level set of disc brakes.
Since you asked, I would recommend the Haro V4. It runs $580 and has significantly better parts than the V3 or Yukon.
Unfortunately with Giant, there are no models between the Yukon @ $470 and the Ranier @ $700.
Anyway, back to your original question...when you compare the V3 and Yukon you are comparing oranges from Florida to oranges from California. The oranges from California are more expensive, but that doesn't make them any better.
You really can't go wrong with either.
Until you hit the $800+ price range, all bikes are pretty much EXACTLY THE SAME. Aluminum frame, Shimano or SRAM components and an entry level fork that does the exact same thing as all other forks in it's price range.
I hate to give you an honest answer, but that's just the kind of guy I am. And get this, I work for the local Haro dealership in town.
I hope this helps.
By the way, according to MTBR.com, both bike have their share of problems.
You get what you pay for. ;D

[seenvic]

I'd agree 100% w/ Ted.

At the price point you are shopping, the thing to look for is service and a relationship with a bike shop that you will be comfortable with.

Which local is the closest (most convenient), has professional staff and can fix what you need fixed. If you get into mountain biking, this will probably be your first bike with another one coming in a year or so....simply because if you really ride you will wear this one out in that time.

I think you need to "shop the shops" as much as shop for a bike. Buy the bike from the shop you like the best and feel like you can have long term dealings with.